I finished revamping a piece yesterday, It’ll end up being either the second or third piece on the album. It took what felt like months of agonizing to accomplish. At this stage, I think I’ve mentioned before, it’s tough to tell “the discipline of the last inch” from scab-picking. How do you tell if you’re applying all this time and brain power to “plus” the piece (to use Pixar’s neologistic verb), as opposed to worrying the fabric of it into non-existence?
Quite forcibly I’ve determined the answer is, you can tell it’s done if, in listening to it, you’re either still unsatisfied or you’re blown away and never want it to end.
Well, I went through every friggin permutation for this piece of music. It’s essentially a pretty straightforward piece. Strings, drums, bass, guitar, shaker and some simple fx. You wouldn’t believe what I went through to try and spiff it up. There is an entire other composition in the waste basket that was to serve as a three minute bridge. I ordered a CD by another Canadian artist so that I could either sample it or get some idea what I could ask for if I hired them to do something original. I spent three friggin days looking for a purchase-able fx track to replace one I’d been using as a place-holder. My DAW choked on my VSTi’s at least fifteen or twenty times, causing me to lose unsaved changes and/or VSTi specs. Hunting for those specs again in a six gig library was no fun at all.
Anyway, it’s a pretty freakin great piece. So with the confidence my first track is fine, and my second one is fine, I listened to my third one again this morning, cringing. It’s good. It’s head a shoulders better than a lot of stuff already on other people’s albums. But it ain’t good enough for me. I realized this morning that I’ve had three distinct composing styles in the past few years, since I started doing this DAW thing.
The first was all canned samples and loops. I just didn’t know anything else was possible, and at the time, I didn’t have my electronic drum kit (couldn’t play a kit anyway), I didn’t have my Motif and I didn’t have the killer softsynths I have now. It was a bigtime learning couple of years.
My second phase was fairly reliant on other people’s midi and arpeggios. All hard and soft synths come with sequencers these days and it’s dang easy to apply wacky riffs to unusual instruments – an organ riff to a bass guitar, for example. As a result, I’ve got a couple of tracks (that I really worked hard on) that rely on these ‘arpeggiators’.
Sucks when you learn something better and look back.
My current phase is all about midi, classical harmony, rich chords and progressions, deep grooves, and complex linear rhythms. This may sound like I’m all fancy-pants trained up the yin-yang. But let me assure you, I’m not. I just glommed onto about sixty ways of cheating. I don’t carry around chord charts in my head. That’s what we have the Internet for. I just listen to everything and pick the progressions that put meat on my musical intentions. You don’t need to be a scholar or an ace session guy to do that.
Anyhoo, I’m now in the unenviable position of having to turf my “middle phase” pieces. I may redo them, I may heave them outright. But it sucks that I got close to having a full album of stuff and now… not. Oh, well… when this thing is finally done, it’ll be pretty dang good. At least I’m more than halfway there.